Connect with us

Jamaica Vision 2030

Part 1: Fish or Fowl – When It Comes To Fare Fixing, Are We In The Public Or Private Sector? – To Achieve Vision 2030 For The Public Transportation Sector A New Business Model Is Needed Now…NTAG

Published

on

The recently formed National Transporters Alliance Group Limited (NTAG) has outlined a very ambitious plan titled – A National Public Transportation Plan For The Jamaican People 2022-2030.

Interim President and CEO of the newly formed National Transporters Alliance Group Ludlow Mclean, is hailing the formation of this cooperative style representation body as game changing for the Public Transportation sector.

The organisation he said was formed to better represent the interest and welfare of Route and Hackney taxi operators islandwide offering rides and last mile delivery services, and courier bikers, all operating through App based technologies.

The plan outlines in some detail what NTAG describes as a new business model based on a number of strategic and fundamental changes and implementation of a technology platform.

The purpose of the NTAG plan is to present a pathway and course of deliberate actions that will improve efficiency, transparency, and fairness, while providing the framework to accelerate the economic growth and development within the public Transportation sector by 2030.

“Our Mission at NTAG is To Achieve Vision 2030 Outcome #9 Of A Modernized Public Transport System That Contributes To Improved Quality Of Life For All Jamaicans.”

In this Six (6) part feature, Businessuite takes an in depth look at the plan for wider public consumption and discussion.

Part 1: Fish or Fowl – When It Comes To Fare Fixing, Are We In The Public Or Private Sector?

“Governments do not expect to make profits from the necessary support for public transportation. An efficient service is important for productivity and other economic benefits that come with moving goods and people. There needs to be a more disciplined approach of how buses are run in urban areas and then those who are served will follow suit. Public transporting should be subsidized. The economic benefits of subsiding will not be direct. The more efficient the public transportation becomes is the more efficient workers become; they reach work on time. They do not have to spend two hours or maybe 30 minutes in traffic” Dr. Lawrence Nicholson The University Of The West Indies

Are We In The Public Or Private Sector? This is a key and fundamental question the plan first seeks to establish, indicating that it must be addressed and clarified without doubt, especially in the matter of fixed and controlled fares.

Government imposed fixed and controlled fares is seen as the most pressing factor impacting investors and operators in the sector, as it directly impacts revenue, profitability and increased investments in the sector.

NTAG poses the following questions.

“Are we operating as private sector entrepreneurs, like the supermarket, gas station,
market vendors, farmers, manufacturers, banks, insurance etc., putting up our own
capital, and paying taxes etc., with the expressed goal to make a decent profit and ROI….If we make a loss that is for our own account.
OR
Are we in the Government operated and controlled Public Transportation Sector offering a public service, supported, subsidised and funded in part by tax payers money, so the Government fixed and controlled fares to the public is lower, as in the case of the JUTC.”

This question is raised against the background of Government policy, as articulated by Finance Minister Nigel Clarke in his 2022 budget presentation where he stated with much fanfare and chest beating that his Government does not believe in price fixing, a very important point to note.

“There is lot of history of failure with the policy of price fixing. History has taught us that when you fix prices, quantity inevitably declines and quality frequently suffers.” Hon. Nigel Clarke Minister of Finance and the Public Service

According to Hon. Nigel Clarke Minister of Finance and the Public Service in his budget presentation on Tuesday, March 8, 2022…. “We do not believe that telling banks what they must charge for a package of services solves this (fee) problem. We hold this view, as we know it would make matters much worse. We don’t believe in telling the market vendor what she should charge for mangoes or the sky juice vendor what he should charge for a bag juice.

There is lot of history of failure with the policy of price fixing. History has taught us that when you fix prices, quantity inevitably declines and quality frequently suffers. The reason is simple: if it is unprofitable to provide the services at the fixed price, the provider will simply choose not to provide the service and then we have a real problem. You can’t compel anyone to operate at a loss.

Also, whenever you try to fix prices instead of dealing with the fundamental underlying malady, the entity whose prices have been fixed will simply pass the costs unto consumers in other, potentially more damaging, ways.

We don’t believe in telling people what to do and in fixing prices. We don’t fix sky
juice price, we don’t fix bulla price, and we are not fixing no price. We do, however, believe in protecting the poor and vulnerable.”

According to NTAG this pointed comment by the Minister clearly makes their case and argument for allowing market forces and not the Government to set prices.

“When I hear people talk about a 15 per cent increase it is relative. That is on a $100 fare. It is not like a private sector employee who would see it as a very good increase because they are getting that on hundreds of thousands of dollars. We are business operators, self-employed individuals. We have been given basket to carry water over the years. We have not got a fare increase in over eight years, and every single thing we consume, to include taking care of our families, we are affected by that as well. Other sectors don’t have to apply to the Government for an increase. We have to apply and wait on them, so it is hard on the sector. We are told to get younger vehicles and when we do we can’t maintain the fleet.”
Sophia Campbell Head Route Taxi Association of Jamaica

NTAG’s position is that we are a private sector group of individual, corporate investors and operators, our firm position is that we are operating as private sector entrepreneurs, like the supermarket, gas station, market vendors, farmers, manufacturers, banks, insurance companies etc., putting up our own capital, and paying taxes etc., with the expressed goal to make a decent profit and ROI….If we make a loss that is for our own account.

NTAG does not support the view that the Government should set prices in the sector and that the forces of the free market should prevail, as outlined in the Governments position firmly articulated by the Minister of Finance in his 2022 Budget presentation.

“The truth is that each operator is licensed as an individual not as a corporation, but the same operator may operate multiple vehicles and each with its own specific road license to a specific vehicle and route. The individual is only required to come through an Association to deal with the Transport Authority, actually creating a cash cow for operators of these Associations. So, the answer to your question is yes an operator should be able to set his own fare structure. The problem it would cause is major disruptions and lots of variances in prices on any given route. Free trade is allowed in Jamaica. Price structuring no longer exist in Jamaica. Gas stations have the right to set his own prices. In fact, some corporate area gas stations have multiple prices in a day to capitalize on the rush hour crowd. What would be needed to make it work, is that every operator on a given route should discuss and agree on the price per route. They could also capitalize on raising the fare each time the gas goes up and decrease each time the gas price decreases”
Marcel Antonio Clarke Transport Sector Investor

Like Hon. Nigel Clarke, Minister of Finance and the Public Service, NTAG believes that the Government has better and more cost-effective ways and means of protecting members of the Jamaican public it deems warrants assistance and support in their public transportation needs. This in much the same way it subsidies the JUTC or provides PATH and other related social services, targeted at those who really need it.

“The operators are complaining about high fuel prices. they have to overcharge passengers in order to survive in a competitive industry.”
Ann Pearl President of the North East Manchester Taxi Association

In his budget presentation on Tuesday, March 8, 2022 Hon. Nigel Clarke, Minister of Finance and the Public Service said.. “We do, however, believe in protecting the poor and vulnerable. We do, however, believe in making more information available and allowing individuals to make their own choices. We do, however, believe that such a system is ultimately superior to one where you are told what to do.

There was a time we used to fix who could bring in food into Jamaica. You know what happened? The business people just set up shop in Miami and became the suppliers of the basic foods to Jamaica. Instead of making their money here in Jamaica, they made it in Miami.

There was a time we use to fix who could import cars. You know what happened?
The restriction created a shortage and led to massive increases in the price of cars.
Knee jerk price fixing doesn’t work, no matter how much you shout or scream. Solving fundamental structural problems work. Freedom works. Protecting the vulnerable works. We believe in delivering targeted support and when we target we go big. As much as practically possible, the Government wishes to direct the relief
towards persons who have been, and are, most affected and who have the least ability to cushion for themselves.”

“I think the time has come for players in the public transport sector to decide whether or not we should continue to call upon government and wait on government for a fare increase. I put it to you that the time has come for the sector to let the market decide on the true cost to travel. The Transport Operators Development Sustainable Services has been for the past several weeks looking at the suggestion by the Minister of Transport Hon Audley Shaw for a review of fares and the subsequent statement by the Minister of Finance Hon Nigel Clarke on the subject of price setting and fixing.
It is my humble view that if the Minister of Finance is to be taken by his words then the policy must be change to let the market decide the fares for the privately-owned public transportation and have a set fare for the government owned public transportation.”
Egeton Newman President Transport Operators Development Sustainable Services

Here again NTAG is in full support and in line with the Minister and the Government that solving fundamental structural problems within the Public Transportation Sector works. Freedom to set fares and prices works, and importantly protecting the vulnerable works. NTAG also believes in the Government delivering targeted support.

Part 2 Public Transportation Sector Cannot Survive On One Foot!

Part 2: Public Transportation Sector Cannot Survive On One Foot – To Achieve Vision 2030 For The Public Transportation Sector A New Business Model Is Needed Now…NTAG

Continue Reading
2 Comments
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Businessuite News24

Why Jamaica Should Now Set Up a Sovereign Wealth Fund: Lessons from Around the World and Pathways Forward

Published

on

In an era where economic stability, sustainability, and growth are increasingly linked to strategic investment, Sovereign Wealth Funds (SWFs) have become pivotal tools for countries seeking to secure long-term wealth and ensure fiscal resilience. From Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global to Singapore’s Temasek, SWFs have enabled nations to tap into their natural resources, surplus revenues, and financial assets to drive economic prosperity. For Jamaica, establishing an SWF could be a game-changer—particularly in strategically important sectors such as technology and logistics—boosting growth, infrastructure, and innovation. But what lessons can be drawn from other nations, and how can Jamaica begin the process?

Global Lessons: Why Sovereign Wealth Funds Were Set Up

Sovereign Wealth Funds are state-owned investment vehicles that manage a country’s wealth generated from surplus revenues. Typically, these funds are built from natural resource wealth, sovereign surpluses, or foreign currency reserves. Countries around the world have set up SWFs to achieve multiple objectives, including:

  • Revenue Diversification: For countries heavily reliant on natural resources (e.g., oil, gas, minerals), SWFs help to diversify income streams by investing in international assets. Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global, for example, was established in 1990 to ensure that the country’s vast oil wealth would benefit future generations. The fund is now valued at over $1.4 trillion, providing a stable source of income and contributing to Norway’s high standard of living.
  • Stabilizing the Economy: SWFs serve as stabilizing mechanisms during economic volatility. For example, the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority (ADIA) was created to manage oil revenue surpluses, helping the United Arab Emirates (UAE) balance its economy during periods of fluctuating oil prices. These funds can also help buffer countries against market downturns and reduce dependence on foreign debt.
  • Social and Economic Development: Some SWFs are designed to invest domestically, driving infrastructure projects, technology innovation, and long-term economic development. Singapore’s Temasek has invested heavily in sectors like technology, finance, and biotechnology, turning Singapore into a global business hub and innovation leader.

Why Jamaica Needs a Sovereign Wealth Fund

Jamaica stands at a critical juncture in its development. While the country has made strides in stabilizing its economy and reducing debt, it continues to face significant challenges in terms of growth, unemployment, infrastructure, and innovation. The establishment of an SWF could address several issues:

  1. Diversifying Revenue Sources: Jamaica has limited natural resource wealth compared to countries like Norway or the UAE, but its burgeoning tourism sector, agricultural exports, and potential in renewable energy could serve as sources for building an SWF. By harnessing surplus revenue from these sectors, Jamaica could reduce its reliance on volatile industries and international borrowing.
  2. Investing in Critical Sectors: With a focus on technology and logistics—two key sectors for Jamaica’s economic transformation—an SWF could directly fund strategic infrastructure projects and innovation initiatives. Jamaica’s logistics sector, in particular, is primed for growth, thanks to its strategic location between the Americas and its modernizing port facilities. Technology, particularly in areas such as fintech, e-commerce, and digital platforms, offers significant opportunities to drive productivity and global competitiveness.
  3. Long-Term Economic Stability: Jamaica’s SWF could serve as a buffer in times of economic crises, reducing the country’s reliance on external loans or foreign aid. By investing in international assets and diversifying revenue, Jamaica could stabilize its economy during periods of local or global market downturns.
  4. Intergenerational Wealth: Just as other nations use their SWFs to secure the prosperity of future generations, Jamaica could use its SWF to ensure sustainable wealth. By building a fund with a long-term investment horizon, Jamaica could improve its fiscal health and create financial security for generations to come.

Case Studies of SWFs in Technology and Logistics Investment

Countries have used their SWFs to strategically boost sectors critical to their economic future. A few notable examples:

  • Singapore’s Temasek: This fund has made substantial investments in high-tech companies, including stakes in global tech giants such as Alibaba and Facebook. By focusing on sectors like technology, innovation, and sustainable energy, Temasek has played a key role in transforming Singapore into a global business and technology hub. Jamaica, with its focus on a digital economy, can benefit similarly by using an SWF to foster its tech industry, from supporting local tech startups to attracting international investment.
  • Norway’s Government Pension Fund Global: While Norway’s SWF primarily invests internationally, it has also funded domestic initiatives related to renewable energy and sustainability, sectors that could align with Jamaica’s Green Economy ambitions. As the world shifts towards renewable energy, an SWF could help Jamaica pivot to clean energy investments, such as solar and wind, helping to both diversify the economy and create jobs.
  • United Arab Emirates’ ADIA: The UAE’s SWF has invested heavily in logistics infrastructure, capitalizing on the country’s strategic position as a global trade hub. The UAE’s investment in ports, free zones, and air freight facilities has turned it into a global logistics leader. Jamaica, with its proximity to key shipping routes, could use an SWF to fund logistics infrastructure such as ports, highways, and transportation systems, strengthening its competitive advantage in the global supply chain.

How Jamaica Can Start the Process

The establishment of an SWF requires careful planning and coordination among key stakeholders, including the Jamaican government, financial institutions, and the private sector. Here are a few steps Jamaica can take to begin the process:

  1. Set Clear Objectives: Jamaica should define the strategic goals of its SWF—whether for stabilizing the economy, diversifying revenue, or funding specific sectors like technology and logistics.
  2. Identify Funding Sources: Jamaica can consider using surplus revenues from key sectors (tourism, agriculture, remittances, renewable energy) as well as potential future revenues from investments in the logistics and technology sectors.
  3. Create a Governance Structure: Establishing strong governance is crucial for ensuring transparency and accountability. The SWF should be managed by an independent body, free from political influence, with a mandate to focus on long-term returns.
  4. Develop Investment Strategies: The fund should target both domestic and international investments, with a focus on sectors that will drive Jamaica’s economic growth, such as technology, infrastructure, and logistics. Investments should be made with an eye toward sustainability, creating jobs, and fostering innovation.
  5. Engage with International Experts: Jamaica should collaborate with international financial experts and countries with established SWFs to gain insights into best practices and avoid common pitfalls.

How It Can Benefit the Jamaican People

An SWF, when managed effectively, could provide significant benefits to the Jamaican people:

  • Job Creation: Investments in technology and logistics infrastructure could lead to the creation of thousands of high-skilled jobs in emerging industries.
  • Economic Growth: By funding key infrastructure projects and fostering innovation, Jamaica could become more competitive on the global stage, attracting investment and boosting exports.
  • Social Benefits: The SWF could fund social projects in education, healthcare, and environmental sustainability, improving the quality of life for Jamaican citizens.
  • Fiscal Stability: Over time, an SWF can provide a steady stream of revenue, reducing Jamaica’s reliance on international loans and enhancing fiscal sovereignty.

Conclusion

Establishing a Sovereign Wealth Fund offers Jamaica a unique opportunity to build a more resilient and prosperous future. By learning from global examples and focusing on strategic sectors like technology and logistics, Jamaica can leverage its natural and human resources to create a fund that ensures long-term economic stability, growth, and social progress. The time is now for Jamaica to explore the potential of a Sovereign Wealth Fund, laying the groundwork for a sustainable and diversified economy for generations to come.

Continue Reading

Businessuite News24

Experience Premium Travel with JUTA Express Powered by InterMetroOne – Corporate Feature

Published

on

Traveling across Jamaica has just been elevated to a new level of comfort, convenience, and safety with the introduction of JUTA Express powered by InterMetroOne. This premium bus and coach service, available through the InterMetroOne app, is set to revolutionize travel for both visitors to the island and locals alike, offering a seamless and luxurious way to navigate Jamaica’s main towns.

A Legacy of Excellence

The Jamaica Union of Travellers Association (J.U.T.A.) has been a cornerstone of Jamaican transportation since its inception in 1974. With chapters in major locations such as Mandeville, Portland, Montego Bay, Ocho Rios, Falmouth, Negril, and Lucea, J.U.T.A. boasts a fleet of over 6,500 vehicles, making it the largest transportation company in the Caribbean. Known for its superior customer service, safe and courteous operators, and exceptional staff, J.U.T.A. has set the standard in public transportation. Their commitment to excellence has earned them numerous awards and a sterling reputation among tourists, locals, and corporate clients alike.

Unmatched Comfort and Safety

At JUTA Express, powered by InterMetroOne, your safety and satisfaction are our top priorities. By partnering with J.U.T.A. we ensure that every journey is handled by professional and dedicated operators who are committed to your well-being. From the moment you board until you reach your destination, you can rest assured that we have your comfort and security covered.

Comprehensive Services

JUTA Express offers a broad range of services designed to meet the diverse needs of travelers. Whether you are commuting for work, heading to school, or embarking on a group tour, we have the perfect transportation solution for you. Our services include:

  • Ground Transportation: Reliable and efficient travel across Jamaica’s main towns.
  • Tourism Transportation: Seamless connections to and from major tourist destinations.
  • Staff and Student Contracts: Dependable transport solutions for educational institutions and businesses.
  • Group Tours and Fun Days: Enjoy organized and hassle-free excursions.
  • Airport Transfers: Stress-free transport to and from Jamaica’s national airports.
  • Conventions and Meetings: Coordinated travel for corporate events and large gatherings.
  • Luxury Coach Buses: Accommodations for delayed flights and special occasions.

Book with Ease Using InterMetroOne

The InterMetroOne app makes booking your travel with JUTA Express simple and convenient. Available on both Google Play and the App Store, the app provides a user-friendly interface where you can plan and manage your trips with ease. With just a few taps, you can schedule rides, track your journey in real-time, and enjoy exclusive perks and rewards.

Why Choose JUTA Express Powered by InterMetroOne?

  1. Professional Service: Experience the best in Jamaican transportation with J.U.T.A.’s highly trained and courteous operators.
  2. Safety and Security: Travel with peace of mind, knowing that your well-being is our top priority.
  3. Comfort and Convenience: Enjoy spacious, air-conditioned buses with complimentary snacks and drinks.
  4. Seamless Integration: Book, track, and manage your trips effortlessly with the InterMetroOne app.
  5. Trusted Legacy: Benefit from J.U.T.A.’s decades of experience and award-winning service.

Join Us on a Journey of Excellence

Whether you are a visitor exploring the vibrant culture of Jamaica or a local navigating your daily commute, JUTA Express powered by InterMetroOne is your ideal travel companion. Download the InterMetroOne app today and discover a new standard of transportation that combines the reliability of J.U.T.A. with the innovative technology of InterMetroOne.

Experience the Difference. Travel with JUTA Express Powered by InterMetroOne.   

 

JUTA’s transportation solution

Continue Reading

Businessuite News24

Should Jamaica Abandon Its 2030 Vision?

Published

on

As a Jamaican employed in an organisation, you are worried about the future of our nation. It appears as if our country is stumbling along, barely keeping its head above water. At the same time, you are aware of the power of a corporate vision.
Why hasn’t someone done the same for our 2.8 million people on the island, and the other 2+ million in the Diaspora?

The good news is that something is already in place in the form of Vision 2030. But why isn’t it changing your everyday experience?

The truth is that we need help. The two main things Jamaicans care most about – economy and crime – seem not to have progressed for decades. Instead, we want the hyper-growth of Trinidad-2004 and Guyana-2023. Or maybe even the steady high performance of the Bahamas.

Or perhaps more importantly, we envy the low crime rates of Barbados or Cayman (formerly a Jamaican protectorate.) At some point, we led all these countries in these areas.

Today, we are working hard not to slip into the same zone as Haiti.

If our leading companies can accomplish so much long-term success, why can’t our country, we wonder? While a direct comparison is unfair, maybe there are a few things we can learn from best practices accepted in your organisation.

A Joined Up, Far-Away Future

A “joined-up” future is one that lots of stakeholders contribute to creating. In a company, it means engaging the board, executives, staff, customers, suppliers, regulators, local communities and more.

Shouldn’t our country do the same?

Based on my experience and queries of colleagues outside government…we don’t know that we already have a joined-up faraway future…at least on paper. In fact, the process used to create Vision 2030 Jamaica from 2003-9 is a world-class model. As such, I have shared it at in-person and online strategy conferences as a case study.

Perhaps you recognise the summary statement: “the place of choice to live, work, raise families and do business.” In times gone, it was the tagline of speeches given by the Governor General, Prime Minister, Leader of the Opposition and many others.

But I looked over the recent Budget Debate notes. I struggled to find much of a mention. A Google search didn’t help. Here are a few ways business people at all levels could intervene now to prevent what former leaders of our country seem to be telling us…this is too important to allow it to be eaten up in regular chakka-chakka.

Why the urgency?

With six or so years remaining until we cross the finish line in 2030, we can’t afford to waste a single moment in mid-race. Remember when Miller-Uibo glanced up at the screen and lost her lead in the 400m final of the 2017 World Championships? We are likely to stumble into defeat also as a nation, unless we pay attention to the following.

A Divisive Election – You and I watch the bitter combat underway in the USA. It appears that cooperation towards common goals is impossible. Within a year, our political parties will try to win the next election by emphasising their differences. This is natural. But it’s the opposite of the intent of Vision 2030 Jamaica. Just imagine if the board of your company were divided into opposing camps. Let’s intervene so that their attention remains on what is most important.

Continuous Inspiration – Your ability to recite our National Pledge and Anthem were picked up as a child. We could elevate Vision 2030 Jamaica to that level of importance, starting with the Forward by Dr. Wesley Hughes, which states in part:

“Today, our children, from the tiny boy in Aboukir, St. Ann, to the teenage girl in Cave, Westmoreland, have access to technologies that were once considered science fiction. They seek opportunities to realise their full potential. This Plan (vision) is to ensure that, as a society, we do not fail them. “

Updated Business-like Measures – How can we know the progress we have made from 2009-2023? Are the measurable results listed in the document beyond reach? Do we deserve an A-? or a D+?

How about fresh, intuitive measures of success which tell us whether or not Jamaica is becoming “the place of choice”? Let’s measure the length of lines outside the US and Canadian Embassies for those seeking permanent residency and how they are growing or shrinking.

Wheeling and Coming Again – Companies have no problem resetting fresh objectives when the old ones no longer do the job. In business, a strategy that is not working is replaced as soon as it’s found to be lacking.

We can do the same for Vision 2030 Jamaica to keep it relevant. This is the beauty of long-term strategic planning.

An honest read of the original document reveals that certain assumptions about the government’s capacity to lead the effort were unquestioned. Today, after over a decade of effort, we have learned much. For example, it’s hard to argue that the planning done in 2009 was enough.

While we once led the world in long-term national planning, we aren’t doing the same in the more difficult world of national strategizing and execution. But there’s time.

As the clock ticks down to 2030, things are likely to become more awkward for all of us. As you may imagine,. the human tendency is to avoid the issue entirely, hoping it goes away.

That may yet happen. But if we don’t confront the gaps in our initial attempt to create a joined-up, faraway vision, we’ll block our citizens from ever believing in a national vision again.

In fact, it would be better if it were declared null and void, than ignored. At least that would have some integrity and enable us to move on to a better national vision, lessons earned.

Better National Strategic Planning

And that is perhaps the biggest lesson for all concerned. We Jamaicans say that we are great starters, but poor finishers. In other words, we know how to kick things off. But when the going gets tough, we aren’t strong at bringing them to fruition.

Said differently, we don’t know how to keep promises just because we made them.

The point here is that Vision 2030, with some five to six years remaining, puts us in an awkward spot. But that’s a lie. We have put ourselves in an awkward spot.

At some point we were strong in envisioning great things. Like a company who creates BHAGs, our executive team gave its sacred honor to accomplish a great thing, like the framers of the Declaration of Independence.

However, we haven’t put in place mechanisms sufficient to rescue our current situation. At the current rate, we won’t be closer to being a “place of choice” than we were in 2009.

In a company it’s easier to find individuals or a team of leaders who may hold themselves accountable for a game-changing result. Often, the metrics are clear.

Unfortunately, no such clarity exists around Vision 2030. And given our impending election fever, it may not come from politicians. Instead, it’s time for business to step up and bring sound strategic planning to the accomplishment of the most important outcomes of our national lifetimes.

Let’s inspire each other to intervene so we can have what we already
know we want. It won’t happen any other way.

Francis Wade is the founder of the Jump Leap Long-Term Strategy newsletter and podcast, and operates a management consulting firm.

Continue Reading

Jamaica Vision 2030

Part 6: The Full Support of Minister of Transport & The Transport Authority – To Achieve Vision 2030 For The Public Transportation Sector A New Business Model Is Needed Now…NTAG

Published

on

Part 6: The Ministry of Transport & The Transport Authority

NTAG notes that the Transport Authority has already begun to make key and fundamental changes that are in line with NTAGs outlined position. This was clearly outlined by the Managing Director of the Transport Authority, Willard Hylton.

We Are Embracing A New Way Of Issuing Licences, Moving Towards A Market-Driven Situation.
“We are embracing a new way of issuing licences, which is currently done on an open-and-closed basis. We will be moving towards a market-driven situation. Under the new arrangement, it will not matter how many persons apply. If there are too many operators on one route, the market will fix that. If someone applies for a route, they will have 30 days to determine if it is working. If not, they can make the change. You have route taxi associations through which our licensees make their applications. We want to strengthen the ability of those route taxi associations to prepare the drivers and operators for Vision 2030. The Authority is looking at how we can start building out something that represents world-class standards, so these changes are necessary. The improvements being made to the transport sector entails more than just having nice-looking buses but also ensuring proper organisation of all modes of public transportation. Whatever we are doing, it should be comparable to what happens in developed countries, so that’s what we are focusing on right now” Managing Director of the Transport Authority, Willard Hylton

NTAG fully supports these initiatives and is dedicated to working with the Ministry of Transport and the Transport Authority to achieve Vision 2030.

“Time and destiny have placed US the stakeholders as leaders at a very important and transformative intersection of the public transportation sector. We now have an opportunity to finally transform the public transportation sector, using technology and our collective efforts. With our collective and unified leadership and support we can do what previous public and private sector leaders in the past have not been able to do…it’s our time to give our Jamaican people what they truly deserve and for US to leave a lasting legacy.” NTAG

I Know WE Can Get It Done!
2022-2030

We Need All Public And Private Sector Stakeholders And Policy Makers Onboard In The Same Room Around The Same Table To Get It Done
The Clock Is Ticking.

Vision 2030 Jamaica – National Development Plan (Extracts)

In 2006, the Government of Jamaica (GOJ) mandated the Planning Institute of Jamaica (PIOJ) to lead the preparation of a comprehensive long-term National Development Plan (NDP) which would place Jamaica in a position to achieve developed country status by 2030. Development of the Plan began in January 2007 and thirty-one Task Forces (TFs) including the Transport Task Force were established thereafter. The TFs represent sectors and areas critical to the achievement of the national goals and have been charged with responsibility for developing the relevant long-term sector plans.

The Transport Task Force through three sub-committees, viz., land, air and maritime transport, commenced the plan preparation exercise in April 2007, leading to the completion and submission of a 1st draft report for the long-term development of the transport sector in Jamaica. Following review and stakeholder consultation, and preparation of an action plan for the sector, the Transport Sector Plan for Vision 2030 Jamaica was completed in 2009.

This Sector Plan for Transport is one of the strategic priority areas of the Vision 2030 Jamaica – National Development Plan. It is one of thirty-one sector plans that form the foundation for Vision 2030 Jamaica – a 21-year plan based on a fundamental vision to make ‘Jamaica the place of choice to live, work, raise families, and do business,’ and on guiding principles which put the Jamaican people at the centre of the nation’s transformation.

Extensive and high-quality infrastructure is considered a pillar of international competitiveness that: enables the efficient functioning of markets for goods, services and labour; increases the productivity of economic processes; and improves decision-making by entrepreneurs and other economic actors. The Transport Sector Plan for Vision 2030 Jamaica will ensure the development of world-class transport infrastructure and services that contribute to the competitiveness of our producers and improved quality of life for our people.

The preparation of the Plan was supported by a quantitative systems dynamics computer model – Threshold 21 Jamaica (T21 Jamaica) – which supports comprehensive, integrated planning that enables the consideration of a broad range of interconnected economic, social and environmental factors. The T21 Jamaica model is used to project future consequences of different strategies across a wide range of indicators, and enables planners to trace causes of changes in any variable or indicator back to the relevant assumptions and policy choices.

Road Transportation

Road transportation, being the larger component of land transportation has been affected by the variations in transportation activities in recent years. Road transport includes the road infrastructure, private motor vehicle movement, and the public transport system including buses and licensed public passenger system. Jamaica has one of the densest road networks in the world, with a total of 15,394 kilometres of road. The length of the road network in Jamaica has incurred some changes due to developments such as the realignment of main roads. There was also the addition of thirty-three kilometres (33km) to the road network due to the construction of Highway 2000 (H2K). Traffic volume has been steadily increasing over recent years. This has led to congestion problems in major towns and capitals across the island. Traffic management initiatives have been implemented in the Kingston Metropolitan Transport Region (KMTR) and proposals have been made to address congestion issues in other parishes.

The Half Way Tree Transportation Centre was opened in January 2008. The Centre is a major transport infrastructure project designed as a modern facility with two levels – one level for arriving buses and the other for departing buses. Ultimately it will provide a single-terminus area for all buses traversing the Half-Way-Tree area. Adequate facilities are in place for the commuting public, including a commercial area with a number of shops and kiosks and offices for the JUTC and TA.

Additional Transport Centres are planned for other areas of the island, although these are not directly under the Ministry’s portfolio. The Urban Development Corporation (UDC) is spearheading plans for a Transport centre in Downtown Kingston. Significantly, there are also proposals by Local Government Authorities to construct municipal transportation centres in areas such as Spaldings, Clarendon and Darliston, Westmoreland.

Public Transport
Under the rationalization of the public passenger transport system in the Kingston Metropolitan Region (KMTR), the Metropolitan Management Transport Holdings Ltd. (MMTH) was established in 1995 with responsibility for purchasing buses and building depots and terminal facilities, while the Jamaica Urban Transit Company (JUTC) was established in 1998 to operate the public passenger transportation system that had previously been provided by private operators. In 2008 there were a total of 1,648 buses licensed to operate in or from the KMTR with a total seating capacity of 39,457. In addition, the Montego Bay Metro provides service on three routes with eight buses.

There was a total of 19,075 taxis licensed by the Transport Authority to provide public passenger service islandwide. The importance of the public transport system to road transport in Jamaica is highlighted by the finding of a recent survey that nearly 75% of households do not own a motor vehicle.

Road Master Plan
The government has undertaken the preparation of a Road Master Plan with funding support from the European Union to guide the development and maintenance of the island’s road network over the next ten (10) years. The main provisions of the Road Master Plan include: identification of priority roads in need of periodic maintenance; estimation of preliminary maintenance and construction costs; and recommendations for funding mechanisms. While the Road Master Plan has not yet been formally adopted by the Jamaican government, the Transport Plan for Vision 2030 Jamaica seeks to ensure continuity in long-term planning for land transport in Jamaica by building on the provisions of the Road Master Plan.

“On May 30, 2018, when Minister Montague rose from his seat in Gordon House, it was in a bid to provide alternate strategies for a beleaguered public transportation system with insufficient units to provide reliable transportation for Jamaicans, not only in the Corporate Area, but also in the rural communities, or the nook and cranny of the island. This inadequacy of public transportation had been identified by the auditor general as a contributor to the growth of illegal public transportation in Jamaica. In fact, in a performance audit conducted by the auditor general in October 2017, it was noted that “an inadequate supply of PPVs may have fostered the prevalence of illegal operators”.
https://jamaica-gleaner.com/article/commentary/20191018/transport-ministry-firm-solving-problems-public-sector

Continue Reading

Jamaica Vision 2030

Part 5: Inability To Attract And Retain Suitable and Qualified Drivers And Conductors – To Achieve Vision 2030 For The Public Transportation Sector A New Business Model Is Needed Now…NTAG

Published

on

Part 5: Drivers And Conductors – Inability To Attract And Retain Suitable and Qualified Drivers And Conductors.

In his budget presentation on Tuesday, march 8, 2022 Nigel Clarke Minister of Finance and the Public Service spoke of the “Inability To Attract And Retain Talent In The Public Sector. It is generally agreed that public sector compensation is not competitive. Public sector compensation, as currently constructed, hinders the Government’s ability to attract and retain talent in the public sector. Those who serve in the public sector do so mainly out of service to country and you will hear the comments from time to time that they are subsidizing government operations. In this regard, trade unions have been advocating for decades for better wages and conditions for public sector workers.”

The Public Transportation sector is also facing a similar dilemma, that of the Inability To Attract And Retain Suitable and Qualified Drivers And Conductors.

“I am focusing on eliminating indiscipline in the transport sector and restoring the railway system. The public transportation system is critical for productivity, and when workers utilise the vehicles they should enter work feeling motivated, and operators in the sector must accept the responsibility that is required from them. We are going to lift our standards in this country, treating people with respect, treating them like human beings, and when they end up at work they feel happy and end up being more productive. Commuters must be able to travel in comfort, and that work will be done to reposition the Jamaica Urban Transit Company (JUTC), as the public transport system is central for students and workers.”
Hon. Audley Shaw Minister of Transport and Mining

As far as NTAG is concerned, and the vast majority of investors in the sector agree, the quality of the available pool of talent from which the sector sources human resources for these roles is grossly inadequate and in need of immediate overhauling. Addressing longstanding issues of job security, working conditions, equity, uneven application of increases, and inadequate salaries is an immediate and urgent priority of NTAG.

One thing Drivers and Conductors in the Public Transportation Sector all have in common is that they all believe that they are not adequately or fairly compensated.
This is a problem.

A vast majority of the public will tell you that they are dissatisfied with the level of public transportation service they receive.
This is also a problem.

Both these problems are related and as a sector we have to address BOTH problems and that is what NTAG proposes to do as part of its vision 2030 plan.

Transport operators who ply sections of St Andrew West Rural withdrew their services on Monday, leaving students and commuters stranded in Half-Way Tree, Stony Hill and other areas. Poor road conditions, seized buses and a demand for fare increase have been cited among the reasons for the strike action.”

Currently drivers and conductors are considered to be independent contractors, as they can choose when, where and how often they work. However, in exchange, they have no job security, vacation pay or other benefits such as pension and health insurance for themselves and family members.
This must change!

NTAG proposes as part of its vision 2030 plan that all registered companies operating in the public transportation sector, as a part of their key strategy execution, must ensure that all independent contractors and operators working in their company have the option and opportunity for job security, vacation pay and other benefits such as pension and health insurance for themselves and family members. This includes payroll payments on a weekly or every two-week basis to allow for accumulated income allowing for better allocation of income for saving, investments, statutory payments and importantly a pay slip. A pay slip provides proof of consistent income allowing for loan applications and other financial requirements.

NTAG will play a major role in ensuring that standards of entry are maintained at a suitable level, and that appropriate training opportunies are always available.

A key feature of this is a project NTAG is working on to develop a cloud based National Transporter Database of Driver and Conductors.

Problem Definition: There is said to be over 200,000 Available Independent Drivers of Public Passenger And Commercial Vehicles who do not own their own vehicle, and will drive for Stakeholders – Investor, Owner And Operator.

However, there is no National Central Addressable And Available Database that can be accessed by these and other stakeholders to view suitable candidates for employment and engagement. In addition, there is no way to reliably determine the work history, experience and expertise of these drivers, and so engagement is often a hit and miss situation. The vast majority of these drivers are transient in that they are not stable in their employment and are known to frequently move around, driving for different investors, owners and operators.

Proposed Solution: The creation of a NTAG National Central Addressable And Available Database that can be accessed by these stakeholders to view suitable candidates for employment and engagement.

A Bulletin Board will also be incorporated allowing Investor, Owner And Operator to post available positions and for Available Independent Drivers to view and apply.

Stakeholders:

National Transporters Alliance Group: Owners and operators of the proposed National Central Addressable And Available Database and responsible for vetting and uploading Available Independent Drivers into the system.

Available Independent Drivers and Conductors: who will apply and have their relevant information uploaded to the database, and pay an annual fee to maintain listing. They will also be able to access and view ONLY their records and file in the database, ratings, comments and recommendations from Investor, Owner And Operator. Ratings and comments from other parties such as passengers and customers should also be available.

Investor, Owner And Operator: These individuals or companies own and operate a single vehicle or a fleet of vehicles, and are seeking to engage Available Independent Drivers. They will apply and have their relevant information uploaded to the database, and pay an annual fee to maintain their listing, and will be able to access and view ONLY their records and file in the database, ratings, comments and recommendations from Available Independent Driver and Conductors. They will NOT have access to another Investor, Owner And Operator information in the database.

They will be able to access and view all Available Independent Driver and Conductors with a limited view of the records and files in the database, ratings, comments and recommendations. Ratings and comments from other parties such as passengers and customers should also be available.

Available Independent Drivers should be able to view limited information on these stakeholders to determine for themselves the suitability of these individuals as employers.

Information and Data Capture: This can begin during the NTAG membership onboarding process as the same information will be required.

Next Part 6: The Ministry of Transport & The Transport Authority

Next Part 4: The Key Stakeholders Required To Make This Plan Work – Investors and Owners – To Achieve Vision 2030 For The Public Transportation Sector A New Business Model Is Needed Now…NTAG

 

Continue Reading

Trending

2
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x